Legally secure means it's clear who owns a piece of music, who stands behind it, and how that can be proven. With AI-generated music, none of these three points hold up. Without a human author, German law recognizes no copyright — and therefore nothing that could be exclusively granted. The song may contain recognizable parts of protected works; the Munich I Regional Court established this for Suno in July 2026 (not yet legally final). Whether a specific track is affected is something the user can hardly check. And since there is no composer, neither GEMA-free status nor GVL-free status can be cleanly proven. Providers like Suno exclude any guarantee.
What "legally secure" actually means for music
Legally secure doesn't mean no one ever asks. It means you can answer every question that comes up. Three questions need to be settled for this — for every license, whether for a YouTube video or a theatrical trailer.
Who owns the music?
There is an author and a rights holder who can be named. Only someone who holds rights can pass them on.
Who stands behind it?
Someone guarantees that the music doesn't infringe on third-party rights — and steps in if it does.
How do I prove this?
License certificate, confirmation of GEMA- and GVL-free status, a cue sheet with authors and performers.
For music composed and produced by humans, these are routine questions. For AI music, every single one fails — for reasons that have nothing to do with the quality of the sound.
Problem 1: No author, no copyright
German copyright law protects only "personal intellectual creations" (Section 2 para. 2 UrhG). Personal means: created by a human. A machine cannot be an author — and the person who gives it an instruction usually isn't one either.
The first court rulings take the same view. In February 2026, the Munich Local Court (Amtsgericht München) ruled that AI-generated logos are not protected — not even after detailed prompts, many iterations, and the selection of the best result. Merely choosing among several suggestions is not enough. In December 2025, the Frankfurt Regional Court (Landgericht Frankfurt) had to assess a song set to music using Suno: the self-written lyrics remained protected. Lyrics generated entirely by AI, however, fundamentally lack the capacity for protection.
Even Suno states in its help section that music created entirely with AI would not be copyright-protected under US law — and that the songs may not enjoy protection even with paid accounts.
- No copyright to grant. A "license" for AI music is primarily a contract with the provider. Whether the recording even gives rise to any separate exclusive right remains unresolved. A mere contract binds only the contracting parties, not third parties.
- Others get the same song. Suno itself points out in its terms of use that an output need not be unique and may be delivered identically or similarly to other users.
- Content ID is effectively ruled out. YouTube requires exclusive rights to the recording for registration. With AI tracks, it's already unclear whether such rights even exist — and other users may receive the same or a similar song.
Problem 2: What's in the model can end up in the song
AI music generators are trained on vast amounts of existing music. For a long time, it was disputed whether any of this remains in the finished model. The Munich I Regional Court has answered this question in the affirmative twice — both times on a complaint by GEMA, both times at first instance and not yet legally binding.
In November 2025, the case concerned OpenAI: the lyrics of nine German songs were reproducible within ChatGPT. The court deemed this a reproduction not covered by the text and data mining exception. OpenAI has filed an appeal; the case is now before the Munich Higher Regional Court.
On July 31, 2026, the ruling against Suno, one of the best-known music generators, followed. It concerned six works, including "Atemlos durch die Nacht," "Forever Young," and "Daddy Cool." The court found that the works are stored in the model and that the generated songs contain their original elements. Given the length and complexity of the pieces, it ruled out that the similarities arose by chance. Suno, not the users with their simple prompts, is responsible for the outputs. The ruling is not yet final.
Simplified summary based on LG München I, judgment of 31.07.2026, Case No. 42 O 763/25 (not final). The court left open how the case would look with detailed user input.
For users, this is a double-edged message. In the proceedings, only lyrics, style, and title had been specified. With input this simple, the court held, the song is attributable to the provider. In the court's view, the situation could be different if someone steers the song deliberately through detailed, repeatedly revised input — but it left that question open. Whether users who later publish such a song are liable was not even part of the proceedings. Anyone who publishes such a song in a video is using it themselves. And under copyright law, a claim for injunctive relief does not require fault: it can be triggered even if you knew nothing about it.
No one will step in to cover this. In its terms of use, Suno expressly excludes any assurance that using the outputs does not infringe third-party rights — and in turn requires users to indemnify Suno against such claims. Contractually, the risk thus lies with the user.
GEMA: "AI-generated" does not mean "royalty-free"
At first glance, AI music seems to elegantly solve the GEMA issue: where there is no author, no one can be a GEMA member either. In fact, GEMA does not accept works that are purely AI-generated. Anyone registering a work must confirm that it was not created exclusively with AI — GEMA does not want to pay out money for content that required no creative work.
The conclusion "therefore royalty-free" is still wrong, for three reasons:
Hybrid forms can be GEMA works
As soon as a human has contributed lyrics or a melody, the track can be registered with GEMA — the Frankfurt ruling shows that self-written lyrics remain protected even alongside AI music. You can't tell by listening whether a song contains a human contribution.
Protected parts remain protected
If an AI song contains elements of a GEMA work, that work is affected. This was exactly the issue in the case against Suno, which GEMA brought on behalf of the authors in its repertoire.
The burden of proof lies with the user
Under the GEMA presumption, publicly used entertainment and dance music is initially presumed to be part of the GEMA repertoire. Anyone wishing to refute this must name the authors for each track and show that they are not represented by GEMA. With AI music, there is no one who could be named.
A study on the GEMA presumption published in 2026 concludes that proving an AI-generated song was created without human contribution and without incorporating protected material would be nearly impossible to demonstrate, given the lack of transparency from AI providers. "An AI made this" is not an answer that settles the question.
On top of that: in September 2024, GEMA became the first collecting society to present a licensing model for generative AI. It provides not only for compensation for training but also for a share in the later use of the generated content — at least to the extent that would apply to works created entirely by humans. The direction is clear: GEMA wants to participate in AI music, not leave it aside.
GVL: the second half remains open
Music has two layers of protection: the composition, for which GEMA is responsible, and the recording, for which the GVL is responsible. The GVL manages the rights of performing artists and record producers — those who sing, play, and produce a recording. How the two relate is explained in the article GEMA-free and GVL-free: the difference.
With AI music, the first group disappears entirely: only a human can be a performing artist. An AI voice does not sing within the meaning of the law, an AI drum kit does not play. The second group, however, remains open. Whether a producer's right (Tonträgerherstellerrecht) even arises for an AI-generated audio file — and if so, whether it belongs to the user or to the provider who organizes and pays for the technology — is legally unresolved.
This leads to the same problem as with GEMA, just from the other side: anyone who doesn't know whether and to whom a right to the recording belongs cannot confirm in writing that it is free. And the traditional record producers, the record labels, did not voluntarily hand over their music for training. They sued Suno in the US; Warner Music only settled its legal dispute in November 2025 with a license agreement.
And then there's the AI Act
Since August 2, 2026, the transparency obligations of the European AI Act (Art. 50) have applied. Providers of systems that generate audio must mark the results as AI-generated in a machine-readable format; for systems that were already on the market before, a transition period runs until December 2, 2026. Anyone who uses AI to create and distribute content that deceptively imitates real people — such as the recreated voice of a well-known singer — must generally disclose this; relaxed rules apply to works that are recognizably artistic.
For users, this mainly means: AI music becomes recognizable. Platforms can identify it using the marking and treat it differently. Spotify, for example, has allowed AI-use information in credits since fall 2025 and says it removed more than 75 million spam tracks in the twelve months before that.
What this means for videos, advertising, and client projects
For anything that is published, sold, or produced for a client, four things belong to a solid license. With any provider, they're worth a quick inquiry.
One rights holder
Who composed it, who produced it? Only someone who holds the rights can grant them.
Warranty with indemnification
The provider warrants that no third-party rights are infringed — and steps in if they are.
GEMA and GVL in writing
A confirmation you can present, plus a cue sheet listing writers and performers.
A clear statement on AI
Reputable providers state explicitly whether generative AI was involved. If this information is missing, it's worth asking.
For a private experiment, AI music may be enough. For a production, it's currently a risk that no one will take off your hands — not the provider, not the platform, and certainly not the client.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is AI-generated music automatically royalty-free?
No. Purely AI-generated tracks can't be registered with GEMA. But if a song contains human contributions or parts of copyrighted works, GEMA comes into play. And since the GEMA presumption applies to publicly used entertainment music, the user must prove the track is free of rights — with authors, which AI music doesn't have.
Do I own a song I generated with AI?
Some providers contractually grant paying customers usage rights or call them "owners." This does not create a copyright: German law protects only personal intellectual creations of a human being. A contract cannot transfer rights that do not exist — and it binds only the parties to it, not third parties.
Is a detailed prompt enough for a copyright?
Under current case law, no. The Munich Local Court (Amtsgericht München) ruled in 2026 that neither detailed prompts, nor numerous iterations, nor selecting from multiple results are sufficient. What is protected is what a human being has recognizably shaped themselves — for example, a self-written song lyric.
Am I liable if an AI song contains a protected work?
In the proceedings against Suno, the Munich I Regional Court (Landgericht München I) attributed the songs to the provider because only simple prompts were given. It left open how the case would look with detailed prompts; the later publication by users was not the subject of the proceedings. However, anyone who publishes a song is themselves using it, and injunctive relief claims do not require fault. Suno, in its terms, excludes any guarantee that the results do not infringe third-party rights.
Am I allowed to use AI music in YouTube videos?
Whether the provider allows this depends on the plan — with Suno, for example, commercial use, even on a monetized channel, is only permitted with a paid account. Either way, it's not legally safe: Content ID is practically out of the question, and there's no protection against third-party claims.
Does SIDtunez use AI for its music?
No. All tracks in the catalog are composed, performed or programmed, and produced by humans; generative AI is not used in their creation. This is explicitly stated in the License Terms (§ 3.2) — along with the rights guarantee, confirmation of GEMA and GVL freedom, and the cue sheet.
In short
AI music isn't risky because it sounds bad, but because it lacks what every license is built on: a human who created it. Without an author, there's no copyright that could be exclusively granted. What's in the model can end up in the song — that's how the Munich I Regional Court saw it in the Suno case. GEMA freedom can hardly be proven without identifiable authors, the GVL side is legally unresolved, and providers like Suno shift the risk onto users by contract.
Anyone using music professionally needs the opposite: tracks by humans whose rights are clarified, with guarantee and proof. That's exactly what SIDtunez offers — every track composed and produced by humans, royalty-free and GVL-free, with license certificate and cue sheet.
Matching Music in the Catalog
All tracks are royalty-free — not registered with GEMA or GVL — and can be listened to directly:
Cinematic Music Trailer music Music by Mood Music for Corporate Videos Music for Documentaries Music for YouTube
Music by humans. Rights that hold.
Composed and produced without generative AI, royalty-free and free of GVL fees — with license certificate, cue sheet, and rights guarantee.
As of October 5, 2026. This article provides a general overview of the legal situation and does not replace legal advice for individual cases. The rulings against OpenAI and Suno are not yet final.
Quellen: LG München I, Pressemitteilung vom 31.07.2026 zum Urteil GEMA gegen Suno, Az. 42 O 763/25 · beck-aktuell zu Ähnlichkeit der Ausgaben und Verantwortung von Suno · CMS zur offengelassenen Frage detaillierter Nutzervorgaben · LG München I, Pressemitteilung vom 11.11.2025 zum Urteil GEMA gegen OpenAI, Az. 42 O 14139/24 · urheber.info zur Berufung von OpenAI · LG Frankfurt a. M., Entscheidung vom 17.12.2025, Az. 2-06 O 401/25 zu einem mit Suno vertonten Song · AG München, Urteil vom 13.02.2026, Az. 142 C 9786/25 zu KI-Logos · GEMA zur Bestätigung bei der Werkanmeldung · GEMA zum Lizenzmodell für generative KI · Bieringer, Die GEMA-Vermutung im Zeitalter der KI-Musik, API Magazin 7 (1), 2026 · iRights.info zu Leistungsschutzrechten an KI-Erzeugnissen · Prigge Recht zum Tonträgerherstellerrecht bei KI-Musik · Suno, Terms of Service (gültig seit 03.09.2026) und Suno-Hilfe zum Urheberrecht · YouTube-Hilfe zu Content ID · itmr zu Art. 50 KI-VO und der Übergangsfrist · Billboard zu den KI-Angaben und Spam-Titeln bei Spotify · Suno-Hilfe zur kommerziellen Nutzung · Music Business Worldwide zur Einigung zwischen Warner und Suno.